Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Grief

I think people react to grief in many different ways, and it affects all people differently. In Holden's case, he chose to take his anger out physically. While reading chapter five Holden lets down his barriers and gives us an inside glimpse of himself. When Holden started talking about Allie, I thought he felt vulnerable and a little bitter, as if he was asking how the nicest and most real person had a shortened life. When Allie died Holden's anger sort of swelled up inside of him until he couldn't take it anymore, and eventually broke his hand breaking all the windows. Honestly I don't blame Holden. I mean, c'mon, his brother just died and he did not know how to express his grief. His brother dying affected Holden a lot more than what he was letting on.  Even to this day he has his hand as a reminder to Allie's death. "My hand still hurts me once in a while, when it rains and all, and I can't make a real fist... but outside of that I don't care much." I think he like having the reminder of Allie with him at all times.
   In a way, I think Allie's death is one of the main reasons Holden can see through these false personas people put up. Holden described Allie as such a real person, and that is why I think Holden is so fed up with all these phonies. You can tell Holden is still dealing with Allie's death because he was so upset when Stradlater ripped up his composition about the glove.  Holden was putting himself out there when he wrote about it, and Stradlater's rejection really hurt Holden, more than anyone would know.  As I said before, I think everyone has their own way with dealing with grief. Some turn to anger or violence while others choose to isolate themselves. I have never had anyone really close to be die before, so I don't know how I will react when the time comes. Allie's death could also be one of the main reasons Holden chooses to isolate himself, because he never really stopped grieving.

3 comments:

  1. I like how you mentioned that everyone deals with grief a different way, and you were really able to grasp what it's like to be Holden. I think you saw the little things that happened earlier in the book that help us see the true Holden.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Amelia. I like how you said that everyone handles grief in a different way. Like how Holden punched out all the glass in the windows and broke his hand, that was just his way of grieving. I also like how you said Allie's death is one of the main reasons Holden can see through people's false personalities. Because since Allie was so real he can tell who is being fake. I never would have even thought to put that together. Great Blog Sylvia :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think you're right on when you say that Holden's grief has led him to put these walls up to the rest of the world. It's like Ernie's bar is a metaphor for how Holden feels in society - lots of people, but no one who truly understands him.

    That being said, don't we all feel like this sometimes? Does that give us room to flunk our classes, drop out of school, and go wander around NYC for a few days?

    ReplyDelete